Happy Valley (Series 2) -BBC 1 (2016) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review


happy valley

I watched the first series of “Happy Valley” on DVD not too long ago.  For some reason I missed out when it was first shown in 2014.  I think I buck the current trend for the box-set guzzling which is changing the face of how we watch TV, in that I often like to have the week-long gap between episodes and I felt that this was very much the case with “Happy Valley”.  Watching the whole series over a couple of days I could appreciate how good it was but it was all a little too intense and grim to be called enjoyable.

For Series 2 I’m reverting to traditional viewing methods – every week at 9pm on Tuesdays.  So far there have been two episodes and on the basis of these this second series is outstanding.  It was one of the many TV shows that I originally thought should stick at just the one series – I didn’t want these characters to be put through any more misery.  I still haven’t got over “Broadchurch” series 2 which managed to diffuse some of the power and television magic of the first series and I’m already getting anxious about a “Dr Foster” Series 2, but maybe “Happy Valley” has restored my faith a little.

Let’s begin with the writing.  Sally Wainwright began her career working on scripts for “The Archers”  and “Coronation Street” (I’ll come back to that later).  I never really fancied her “Last Tango In Halifax” although now I know I’ve missed out.  For me she really came up trumps with “Scott and Bailey” – the ITV police drama which features four of the best parts written for women in recent years, the two title roles (Lesley Sharp and Suranne Jones), their boss DCI Gill Murray (Amelia Bullmore) and in the third series Rachel Bailey’s mum played by Tracie Bennett.  Three out of four of those actresses established themselves in “Coronation Street” (I’ll come back to that again later).


Wainwright’s writing is spot on.  It is dialogue that can turn on a knife edge.  The series opener began with Police Sergeant Catherine Cawood and her sister Clare in conversation about Catherine’s day at work.  What starts off as a humourous story about urban sheep rustling turns decidedly grisly, then veers back into black comedy and then becomes deadly serious with an unexpected development all in the space of the first five minutes.  In Episode 2 a jokey bantery scene between Catherine and her team switches instantly once a foolhardy PCSO oversteps the mark.  These changes of mood and tempo are something which Wainwright always does so well.  This has the effect of having you hang on to every word and holding your breath when watching.  (I do this with “Scott and Bailey” as well as “Happy Valley”).

Now the casting.  It seems at last it is being recognised that “Coronation Street” alumni are amongst the best actors on television.  The casting team of “Happy Valley” know this as four of the main parts have been given to strong ex-Corrie character actresses- Sarah Lancashire, Katherine Kelly, Julie Hesmondhalgh and Amelia Bullmore (again).  All are turning in exemplary performances showing there is life after the cobbles and I’ve now forgiven all of them for leaving “Coronation Street” well before their time was up.

happyvalley9 happyvalley4


happyvalley7 happyvalley14


From the Street To The Valley

Famous faces from other shows are also excelling – Siobhan Finneran (Benidorm/Downtown Abbey)  is reprising her role as Cawood’s sister.  Back in 2000 Lancashire and Finneran worked closely together on a superb episode of the series “Clocking Off” (Yvonne’s Story – Series 1) which showed the strength of the chemistry between these two and I’m delighted to see them back together.  (This will be my last reference back to “Coronation Street” but this episode featured in the role of Lancashire’s children Jack P Shepherd and Tina O’Brien in their pre-Street casting as the Platt brother  and sister they’re still both playing today).   The outrageously versatile James Norton, fresh from his turn as heroic love interest Prince Andrei Bolkonsky in “War & Peace” is back to scare the living daylights out viewers as Tommy Lee Royce.  Of the new faces Finneran is joined by Downtown Abbey cast-mate Kevin Doyle (who’d have thought we’d have seen Mr Molesley’s bum on TV?) who’s playing a blinder and from episode 2 an excellent performance from veteran actress Angela Pleasance as neighbour Winnie.  Shirley Henderson is absolutely spell-binding as Royce obsessed Frances Drummond.  In the series opener there is an extraordinarily disturbing prison visit where by just sitting too close to Royce she is speaking volumes about the character.


Two episodes in and I’m confident that Sally Wainwright will be able to entertain, thrill and horrify me in equal measures.  I have absolutely no idea where the series is going and don’t want to know, no plot-spoilers from me here.  I would expect this to be recognised by Bafta as was the first series and it could end up being one of the TV highlights of the year.



Happy Valley is broadcast on BBC1 on Tuesdays at 9pm.  Episodes should be available on the BBC I-Player catch up service.

10 thoughts on “Happy Valley (Series 2) -BBC 1 (2016) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review

  1. Monika McKay

    Hi Phil,

    Hope, I managed to write all my points.
    Firstly, I totally agree with you that the first series of Happy Valley is not enjoyable to watch one episode after another. You need a break from all the tension and intensity…(not a complaint, just an observation.)
    Now before I forget, you mentioned Scott and Bailley. Never watched it, so can’t comment. But viewed a couple of performances of Lesley Sharp and thought myself, how on earth is this woman an actress? My questioned was answered recently in the BBC1 drama (can’t remember the name) about a London Street and going ons…. Lesley Sharp played a daughter to an elderly widowed woman, terminally ill, who lived on the street all her life. Her performance as emotionally torn daughter, who would prefer her mother would sell the house and moved closer to her, so she could look after her. Well, her performance in this series was one that persuaded me she can act, indeed.
    Sorry, back to Happy Valley.Siobhan Finneran stole the show with her alcohol problems in the 2nd part. (I loved her performance in Downton Abbey, Benidorm). The character of a shop assisstant, who goes to blackmail the CID officer (Mr. Mosley in Downton Abbey) was so strong in the first part that it instantly made me feel full of hate…(powerful writing).
    Shirley Henderson’s performance is so intense. But I have to admit to reading up on her character in the TV choice, otherwise would not guess, how well she fits in the whole storyline.

    A little complaint though. And it is to do with a producer, a director and sound. Sarah Lancashire’s diction is muffled. It is not a question of putting the sound up or lip reading (I wish), I just cannot understand when she speaks. Is it a matter of putting Yorkshire accent on?
    In comparison to Siobhan (Clare, Cathrine’s sister)? I am surprised nobody like a director /a producer pointed it to her to speak clearly. There is nothing wrong with my hearing. And if I have difficulties, what chance have those viewers who have?


    1. Good points, Monika. I don’t think you are alone with the muffled diction dilemma. I had heard there were complaints about that before I watched the first episode so I put the subtitles on. I didn’t think it was that bad (nothing like the BBC’s adaptation of “Jamaica Inn” which I gave up on). I didn’t use the subtitles for the second episode although there were a couple of times when I missed things and then rewound and put the subtitles on. When the writing is so good you don’t want to miss a thing, do you? It was, admittedly, Sarah Lancashire that I had to go back to and it seemed to be an issue when she is talking to just one other person and things are said as asides. There was the scene with her sister when they were talking about the man her sister had hooked up again with that I found myself rewinding. Maybe it is accent, not sure. The BBC do get a bit of a hard time for mumbling and I do think they should be more aware of this – but they are not the only culprits. Nearly all American films and TV shows I have to put the subtitles on and I don’t think it’s to do with accent or my hearing. I hope it doesn’t put you off your viewing of “Happy Valley”. I see the BBC say they are looking into it…………………


  2. Kay Carter

    What have I missed? I didn’t see the first series so I didn’t bother with this one. To be honest I’m usually in bed by nine, but it sounds as though I have missed a real treat. Will have to start recording it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. So far so flippin’marvellous! Aren’t we all in bed by nine? That’s what the record button is for. I must admit I was very late to pick up on the first series – and that was because it won lots of awards so I thought I could have been missing out. I don’t think its essential to have seen the first series to enjoy this


  3. Pingback: The Amazing Mr Blunden (1972) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review – reviewsrevues

  4. Pingback: Coronation Street (2016) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review – reviewsrevues

  5. Pingback: SS-GB – BBC1 (2017) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review – reviewsrevues

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s