I’m feeling a little discombobulated. Firstly, congratulations are due to highly esteemed American author Saunders who comes onto the shortlist much praised for his previous published works which includes essays, short stories and novellas. This is his first full-length novel and its arrival was much anticipated.
I’m disturbed firstly because it is distinctly odd. The whole thing is written as observations, either as quotes from books or character statements. These are often in short sections and in common with first-hand sources can be contradictory so you get different opinions of the same event. This does make it quick to read but the short length of these breaks up any real flow. It does on occasion lead you in almost addictively when there’s a barrage of different views on an event, but generally, although it is undoubtedly cleverly done, it feels a little too much like style over substance to me.
The subject matter also disturbs. It’s very much an account of grief. President Abraham Lincoln’s young son dies of a fever. The “Bardo” is a graveyard-set half-life where spirits who have not yet resolved themselves to their demise drift in a shape-shifting existence and are joined by the spirit of Willie Lincoln. This disparate group of beings from the cemetery and mass graves beyond attempt to reconcile the boy to his death. At times these sections reminded me of Neil Gaiman’s “Graveyard Book” and what I couldn’t get out of my head was a manic, adult version of “Rentaghost”.
The whole thing just feels a little off-kilter. Anyone actually experiencing grief or recent bereavement would be advised to steer clear. This was the bookies’ early favourite to win the Man Booker Prize. Do I think that this should get the prize for the best work published in English this year? No, I don’t and perhaps I might have enjoyed the whole thing more if I wasn’t aware the whole time if this wasn’t stirring around in my mind and that the judges favoured this over longlisters “The Underground Railroad” and “Home Fire”. I will give it points for cleverness and originality but the style and theme are just too unsettling for me to really get behind this one.
Lincoln In The Bardo was published in March 2017 by Bloomsbury
5 thoughts on “Lincoln In The Bardo – George Saunders (2017) – A Man Booker Shortlist Review”
Pingback: Man Booker 2017- Is it possible to pick the winner? – reviewsrevues
Pingback: Barneys, Books And Bust-Ups (BBC4 2018) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review – reviewsrevues
Pingback: McGlue -Ottessa Moshfegh (2017) – A Murder They Wrote Review – reviewsrevues
Pingback: Hot Stew- Fiona Mozley (John Murray 2021) – reviewsrevues
Pingback: Harlem Shuffle – Colson Whitehead (Fleet 2021) – reviewsrevues