Collateral (BBC2 2018) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review

watching

collateral

Award-winning playwright David Hare’s first foray into a television drama series began this week with an impressive cast.  Sir David was knighted in 1998 for services to the theatre, namely a string of West End and Broadway successes.  He has received Oscar nominations for his work in films (including his adaptation for the excellent 2002 movie “The Hours”) and enjoyed a lengthy career in television  with films and plays which began back in 1978.  His “breakthrough” play “Slag” was first performed at The Royal Court in 1970.  What we have here is a heavyweight, influential writer but would these skills transfer to a modern-day police drama shown over a period of four weeks?  I think those members of the audience who knew of Hare’s work would have viewed this with extremely high expectations.  Those who knew he is married to French fashion designer might have expected something rather stylish along the lines of “The Night Manager” or “McMafia” but probably the majority who found themselves watching at 9pm on Monday evening were just after their dose of police procedural drama.  I’m not sure who would have ended up at the end of the first episode the most satisfied.

collateral2Carey Mulligan in “Collateral”

Central character DI Kip Glaspie is played by Carey Mulligan, who I recently watched doing impressive work in “Mudbound” (2017) and whose 2015 turn in “Suffragette” is currently languishing on my Sky Planner.  We find out that Glaspie was once a champion pole vaulter for reasons which are not clear but any potential vaulting through a suspect’s open window seems unlikely as she is also pregnant.  (I don’t think it’s that kind of production anyway, but it did suggest some thrilling action sequences in my head when another character mentioned it!)

A pizza delivery man is gunned down on the streets of London just after delivering a pizza to harassed mum (Billie Piper) who, inexplicably, ends up throwing the uneaten pizza into a corner of a room.  Piper’s character is edgy and distracted and is the ex-wife of local MP played by John Simm (who was also in equally high profile ITV drama “Trauma” this week, which I chose not to watch).  Simm’s character was fleshed out in a bedroom scene with recent girlfriend played by Kim Medcalf (a former Sam Mitchell on “Eastenders”) in  a scene which oddly seemed to suffer from some really heavy-handed dialogue in what I believe had the intention of illustrating him as a man who puts politics above people.  Also in the mix is the always value for money, Nicola Walker, fast becoming a staple of all television drama, who is playing a lesbian vicar with a secret which suggest Simm’s character is not as exactly above board as he would like to make out.

collateral4

Billie Piper and John Simm

The dead pizza delivery man turns out to be an illegal immigrant living with family members in a lock-up garage which instantly adds political weight to the drama.  By the end of the episode the killer but not the motive is revealed.  With Ben Miles and Saskia Reeves also in the cast I don’t doubt that we will be seeing strong performances but on the evidence of this first episode I’m not sure if the writing feels natural enough for this kind of production.  I found the superbly written “Happy Valley” and “Scott and Bailey” coming to mind.  Here there were a few times I felt the lines jarring on me.  It might be Hare’s deliberate intention to unsettle us as this is obviously going to be much more than a tale of a killing on a South London street but it is not clear exactly where it is going yet.

collateral3

Sir David Hare

I suspect that like BBC 1’s “McMafia” which shed a lot of viewers (although I stuck with it without being totally sure why) a number who watched the first episode may not be back for more despite the cast and obviously high production values.  I’ll give Episode 2 a go but most confess there was nothing in this episode which really lodged in my mind.  Often when I sit down to write a review I can get writing with what has stayed with me.  Here I had to flick through the programme again just to remind me what had gone on – and I’m not sure if that is a positive sign.

threestars

Collateral is on BBC2 on Monday’s at 9.00.  The first episode is available on the BBC I-Player.  Internationally, it has been picked up for inclusion on Netflix.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Collateral (BBC2 2018) – A What I’ve Been Watching Review

  1. My colleague saw this and when asked what it was like, she said she was bored and turned it off half way through. After reading your review maybe I won’t bother trying to get it on catch up.
    We don’t have Netflix and I struggle to find anything decent on t.v. even with all the Sky channels available. I have been watching the original Law and Order with Jerry Orbach and Sam Waterston, I’ve seen these umpteen times, and Inspector Gently.
    I have, however, been watching from the start, the original Mapp & Lucia.

    Like

    • I must admit with the Sky channels I’m struggling and beginning to question whether my Sky subscription is worth it. I just love using the Sky Planner though and never watch anything “live” – I record everything. Interesting about Mapp and Lucia. I remember the original series so fondly and watched it a few years ago on DVD and loved it all over again. However, a couple of years back bought it on DVD and it wasn’t how I remembered and it seemed a bit amateurish. We watched the first episode and didn’t watch any more. Maybe I should go back to it………..

      Like

  2. 10 mins it took to change the channel. Was curious, as stellar cast, couldn’t follow at all…CONFUSING to follow it, didn’t get what (the actress from Spooks) was supposed to contribute to the script…chopping and changing scenes…Thank you very much…VERY POOR.
    didn’t watch Trauma, don’t do this kind of social ethical aspects, too much sophisticated for ME personally. I understand it wants to show, how shady areas -conflicts- in a surgeon – can play havock within…but I find it FAR TOO OF REALITY, more like some undermined, frustrated writor’s attempts…

    Like

    • I didn’t watch “Trauma” as it seemed too hospital based and legal for me. Collateral, I still haven’t made up my mind. 10 mins in was probably the odd first scene with John Simm in. Around this time I might have been tempted to change the channel but the cat was on my lap! Things did drop more into place as the episode progressed but I’m not convinced it’s the major success I was led to believe it was going to be.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s