A Love Trilogy -Donna Summer (Casablanca 1976)
UK Chart Position – 41
US Chart Position – 21
The worldwide success of Donna Summer’s debut hit “Love To Love You Baby” took everyone by surprise. The singer spoke of the recording of it as just messing around in the studio and did not expect it to be a single. Recorded in Munich, it was the producers Giorgio Moroder and Pete Bellotte’s nod to another controversial European success, the French legend Serge Gainsbourg’s and English actress Jane Birkin’s “Je T’Aime Moi Non Plus”. Like the French track, the steaminess ensured that it was not going to get many daytime radio plays. With Disco becoming increasingly a commercial force this track took off and when Neil Bogart, head of Casablanca records heard it, he demanded a longer track. Moroder and Bellotte extended it to an 18 minute epic and put it out on one side of Donna’s second album release, named after the track. This is the song that paved the way for the 12 inch single and pop music was never the same again.
It became a huge hit and the album was propelled into charts worldwide on the strength of this track alone. I believe the 7” version which was released on the GTO label in the UK and got to number 4 is one of the greatest singles of all time. (I think the US had a slightly different edit, which didn’t build to the great choral “Love to Love you baby baby” bit towards the end). As an entire side of an album it felt overly stretched and somewhat looped. There isn’t the great progressive build of the single. The rest of the album, apart from the single’s b side “Need A Man Blues” and the fragile ballad “Whispering Waves” indicated the speed with which it had been put together to capitalise on the title track’s demand and consisted of largely throwaway pop/rock tracks where the artist lacked a clear identity.
Donna Summer with Giorgio Moroder
With this second album a lot of learning had taken place and all that learning is synthesized (in more ways than one) to produce an absolute classic recording-the finest of Donna’s career and the zenith of her work with Giorgio Moroder and Pete Bellotte. In the intervening months since the release of the previous album Disco had continue to grow as a musical force and the world was ready for an album that was out and out disco and not one that contained a couple of disco-friendly tracks over a mishmash of soul, R&B and pop. Technically, the production team had also moved on and were able to achieve a greater, more coherent electronic sound than on the previous album. Skills that were continue to build until they came up with one of the most important dance tracks of all time with the genius “I Feel Love” a complete game-changer a couple of years later- but that was still in the future.
Although I played the single “Love To Love You Baby” until it virtually wore out I did not, at the time, buy the album. It just didn’t seem very good value, when I knew I had the best tracks as a single but I was determined to buy this one as soon as it was released. On the GTO label in the UK it was a thick slab of vinyl, for some reason, it was certainly the thickest album I ever owned. When vinyl got wafer-thin and the edges razor-sharp by the mid 80’s when we were being pushed to buy CDs, putting on “A Love Trilogy” felt reassuring and solid. And play it I most certainly did. There must be very few albums I have played more than this one over the years.
Whilst browsing on Amazon I discovered a review for this album that I’d written 15 years ago, back in 2003. I think this is the very first review I ever published, so motivated was I to keep this album in the public consciousness and that review is still there today with the massive total of 25 people who have found it helpful! Here is what I said back then:
Summer’s second album is superb. At various times in my life I have worked out what my favourite albums or CDs would be and this one is always there somewhere – it is an album which meant so much to me at the time, I knew every single note of it. Amazingly, it still sounds outstanding today. It was the follow up to her “Love To Love You Baby” album, which was a decidely hit or miss affair and did not suggest that Donna would be around too long as a recording artist. The format is similar, with one long track which took the whole of the first side of the vinyl version and three shorter tracks on the second side. The long track (at 18 minutes) is “Try Me I Know We Can Make It” which is broken down into sections like “Try Me”, “I Know”, “We Can Make It”, before coming together for (you guessed it) “Try Me I Know We Can Make It”. A single was released but it was nowhere as good as the extended mix. It became a small hit in the States but didn’t really do a great deal of business over here in the UK. “Could It Be Magic” was the stand out track, a cover version of a Barry Manilow song, which was just so exciting made even more so by a breathy spoken introduction and a middle section which many ways seemed even ruder than “Love To Love You Baby”! How this wasn’t a huge hit I will never know- the Take That smash revival of the song seemed to owe more to this version than to Barry’s. I was obsessed by this album- I played it over and over again. It seemed so creative, so very then. I would still argue that it was Donna’s best album – yet sales wise it certainly did not capitalise or build on the success of the first album. Do not miss out on this CD.
The back cover of the original vinyl LP
Fifteen years on and I agree with every word. Why this was so far superior to what had come before was largely due to the “Try Me, I Know We Can Make It” track. True, it is largely made of those eight words repeated in various combinations many times over but the whole thing really builds and feels a much more organic piece than the extended version of “Love To Love You Baby”. There is so much going on here and it is so creative. It really is Moroder’s masterpiece. Also, what works well is that the Summer-Moroder-Bellotte partnership here feels equal and this is as much the producers’ album as the vocalist. Donna’s vocals are often wispy and ethereal, sounding as if she’s been recorded in an oxygen tent but it gives the whole thing a beauty and vulnerability and makes the sound extremely intimate (if an eighteen minute disco epic could be called intimate). The mystique of Donna Summer the artist is still strong here. You can’t tell exactly how good a singer she was (that was the case on the first album). Also, like the first album you can’t really tell what she looks like from the album cover which opted for soft focus- maintaining the 70’s soft-core porn aesthetics which had adorned the art work of “Love To Love You Baby”. There was still mileage to be had in portraying her as a kind of mythical sex goddess, which fitted in superbly with the hedonism of disco.
I would imagine Donna would come to hate this picture but it fitted in with the mood of the time.
I still think “Could It Be Magic” is the stand-out track but the second side of the album was not plumped out by filler as its predecessor had been. “Wasted” and “Come With Me” are both great tracks which fit in well with the concept of the album and also sound great on their own.
Photographers were also keen to convey a more wholesome image
Commercially, it may have been a little ahead of its time. In the UK the Manilow cover version got to number 40, just one place above where the album stalled. It would be many years before Donna would again put out an album that did not have a US Top 40 single on it but I think this was never a singles album. It is heard best as a whole. The Canadians got it, as it became a Top 10 album there, reaching a higher position than “Love To Love You Baby” had but for most markets, commercially it was a bit of a backward step for Donna and The Munich Machine. I think Donna sounds great throughout and that the production team of Giorgio Moroder, Pete Bellotte, arranger Thor Baldurson and engineers Juergen Koppers and Mack & Hans, on the evidence here demand recognition as being amongst the most important pioneers of electronic dance music.
A Love Trilogy is currently available from Amazon in the UK for £14.83 and used from £8.21. It can be downloaded for £7.09 . In the US it is available for $7.39 and used for $2.39. In the UK it is available to stream on Spotify.