This is a book which often appears in best crime series debuts and mystery/thriller recommendations lists. I did the unusual thing (for me) of reading the third in this series “Smoke And Ashes” when it came out in 2018 and with the recent publication of the fourth in paperback I thought I’d start off at the proper place – the beginning- especially as I enjoyed very much the book I did read.
“A Rising Man” introduces Police Captain Sam Wyndham, recently arrived in Calcutta in 1919 and billeted in a British run guest-house where the food he is served up puts him at greater risk from illness than if he took his chances on the streets of Calcutta.
He is called to a street murder of a senior Civil Servant and he meets up with Surendranath Banerjee, nicknamed “Surrender-not” by British officers unwilling to learn the correct pronunciation of his name, who becomes Wyndham’s sidekick in this series. The pair set out to uncover the murderer amongst growing unrest in the local population which comes to a head when news of a massacre by British troops in Amritsar travels to Calcutta.
This novel won the 2107 Historical Dagger at the Crime Writers Awards so I was expecting big things. I was impressed by it but I think I just slightly preferred “Smoke And Ashes” which felt a little pacier and by which time Abir Mukherjee had confidently established the characters. Wyndham’s flaw is a predilection for opium as a result of the trauma of the war years and the loss of his wife in the flu epidemic straight afterwards, an addiction which he will certainly have the opportunity to explore in early Twentieth Century Calcutta.
This is a strong debut with a satisfactory conclusion and has set the series up appealingly and I am keen to seek out the other titles.
A Rising Man was published by Harvill Secker in 2016. I read the 2017 Vintage paperback edition.
One thought on “A Rising Man – Abir Mukherjee (2016) – A Murder They Wrote Review”
Another to add to my growing list.
Sounds right up my street. I’ve read a few recently that have been ok. Have to finish to see if you solved the murder way before the detectives. So far only a few I haven’t bothered to finish.
Looking for something new.
Will definitely seek these out.