This entertaining novel sees Emma Stonex (her first written under her own name) taking as her inspiration the disappearance of three lighthouse keepers in the Outer Hebrides in 1900. She moves the action 72 years forward relocating it to the Maiden Lighthouse in Cornwall and within her fictional account attempts to unravel this mystery.
In many ways it is a classic locked room thriller. The men are found missing from the lighthouse which is bolted on the inside with food preparations on the table and clocks stopped at the same time.
Alongside this narrative the author focuses on twenty years later and the wives and girlfriend of the three missing men as they are approached by a novelist wanting answers for his latest book.
What I feel is done very well is the 70’s set lighthouse sections which conveys the intensity and boredom of the three men cooped up together. I felt that the more modern sections did not establish the characters as well, although, obviously, it is within these parts that the secrets of the past are revealed in first and third person narrative and through letters.
I was most intrigued by the almost romantic allure that the lighthouse had for the keepers whilst also acknowledging the reality of spending their working lives in a small inescapable space cooped up with others. The book both builds up the appeal of this work as well as illustrating the downsides. After months of lockdown I think we are all in a better position to appreciate better Stonex’s writing and have stronger ideas of these lives than we would have done a year or two ago, making this a very commercially apposite proposition.
The author makes no assumptions as to what happened during the real-life disappearance in 1900 but comes to a conclusion as to her characters. At times I felt this might go in some outlandish direction but it all feels plausible and in some ways that felt a little anti-climatic, I almost wish she had left things a little more open-ended, which was an unusual response because surely the motive behind reading the book would be to find out what happened..
This was one of the titles that I highlighted for 2021 in my Looking Back Looking Forward post . I enjoyed Emma Stonex’s writing and look forward to seeing what she comes up with next.
The Lamplighters is published by Picador in the UK on Thursday 4th March 2021. Many thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for the advance review copy.