The me of 16 years ago read this South African author’s breakthrough novel which had been shortlisted for the 2003 Booker Prize. I had to check back through my records to see that in the winter of 2005 I quite enjoyed “The Good Doctor”, his tale of a remote rural hospital and thought it well-written but I felt it had failed to draw me in and my verdict was that it was unexceptional. To be honest, I had forgotten all about this opinion when I was invited by the publishers to review his latest title. I was assured a novel “confident, deft and quietly powerful” and “literary fiction at its finest”. I was intrigued.
If “The Good Doctor” failed to draw me in 16 years ago then things were soon put right with this. I was very involved early on and it is the self-assurance of the writing and his handling of life-changing events which kept me hooked. The Swart family live on a farm outside Pretoria and we visit them at various moments in their lives. It is the tale of four deaths and the coming together of those left. Linking these occasions is a promise 13 year old Amor believes she has heard her father making to her dying mother, a promise which is denied, ignored or postponed for decades due to circumstances within the country and within the family. The strength is in the characterisation and interactions between the family members. The tragic trigger points which cause the reunions roll back the preceding years with great economy and truth by the author. I loved the structure of this novel, some demises are tragic, some violent, some tragi-comic but all imbued with a sense of South African history which is extremely effective. There is an appealing calmness which runs alongside the tragedies. It makes me think that the older me might have a greater appreciation of “The Good Doctor” and I would be very interested in discovering more work (Galgut’s published oeuvre consists of novels, short story collections and plays) by this author.
The Promise will be published in the UK by Chatto & Windus on 17th June 2021. Many thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for the advance review copy. The Kindle/ebook edition is published by Vintage Digital.