Another book from my What I Should Have Read In 2020 post (I’ve now managed to get through 60% of these). Here was one I suspected that I would really like but I enjoyed it even more than I imagined. This is American author Brit Bennett’s second novel and after this I would certainly be keen on seeking out her 2016 debut “The Mothers”.
This, however, is the book that has established her breakthrough into the big time, appearing on so many Best Of The Year lists and has been shortlisted for the 2021 Women’s Prize for fiction. The hype has built up which is often a dangerous thing for me and my expectations, but I’ll emphasise this, my expectations were exceeded here.
I came to it knowing roughly what it was about but there was so much more to it . Two light-skinned black twin sisters disappear from their small-town home and head for the excitement of New Orleans. One, Desiree, eventually pairs up with an abusive, dark skinned man and has Jude, whose blue-black darkness of her skin shocks the residents of her home town, Mallard (where its black residents generally have a much lighter tone) on her return whereas her twin, Stella, ditches Desiree to disappear once again and decides to “pass” and live her life as a white woman. In a decades spanning time frame we have as our starting point 1968 when Desiree returns to Mallard with her young daughter.
There are so many discussion points in this novel regarding identity that one might expect it to feel issue-driven but no, plot and characterisation are both very strong and that together with its immersive readability provides an extremely impressive rounded work. Those plot lines and unpredictable turns do drive the reader forward. It’s not without a healthy dollop of melodrama and on a few occasions the authors use of cliff-hangers resembles the soap operas that one of the characters makes a name for herself on, but this is also a good thing, making it feel highly commercial, this together with its relevance where its publication alongside the media coverage of the Black Lives Matter movement created publicity at a time when lockdown ensured the usual avenues of publicising their work were not open to most authors. This book deserved the exposure, however, not because it was of the moment but because of the sheer quality of the handling of all areas of the book.
Performance has a major part to play. Many of the characters are donning a disguise and playing a part, some professionally and some within their lives and even within their closest relationships. I found the implications and repercussions of this fascinating. It has the unusual advantages of being both a thought-provoking important novel and a great holiday read and I hope many more people will discover this work over the summer. My only criticism of a book I found very difficult to put down is that perhaps the ending felt a little flat and less defined than I would have hoped but that may have been because it was the end of the novel and there was no more to read about these characters.
The Vanishing Half was published in the UK by Dialogue Books in 2020. The paperback edition is out now.