Pakistani author Taymour Soomro’s debut sees teenage Fahad very reluctantly accompanying his father to his upcountry farm estate in Abad, an area developed largely from jungle as his power-hungry father is keen to tell everyone. Fahad would rather spend his summer with his mother in London or Karachi but Rafik wants to toughen him up, show off his own power and influence in the area and present Fahad as the next generation.
Fahad is unable to fit into his father’s image of him. Things seem to improve when ex-London resident and Rafik’s cousin Mousey returns home but his motives challenge Rafik’s plans. A young man, Ali, is introduced to Fahad as a role model but Fahad finds himself attracted to him.
Tradition and the importance of family are two unsurprising themes here with those unable to sustain those values being swept aside. The characters are unable to express their feelings to one another causing long lasting frustration and resentment. Rafik’s need for power and prestige cannot allow anyone to stand in his way.
The story is well told and there are some lovely moments especially in the interactions between characters, Fahad with the “young thug” Ali and also with his aging father in the latter stages of the novel but for me it did not have the resonance I was expecting.
The author switches from father to son’s perspective within the third person narrative and there are jumps in time which gives a jerky, disjointed feel at times which sometimes I can actually appreciate in novels but here I think it affects the reader’s relationships with the characters.
I didn’t feel that I knew the characters well enough. There is so much potential within the cast here, Rafik, Fahad, the mother, father’s cousin Mousey and Ali have all potential to blend into something outstanding but I felt the author was only allowing me to have a superficial understanding of them as if something was being held back. I felt this particularly with main character Fahad, on this occasion leaving the reader to fill in the gaps influences the reader’s response to him. I felt I wasn’t being pulled in to the novel as consistently as I could have been.
I do feel however that Taymour Soomro has provided us with a very visual work and there are considerable poignant, subtle scenes. A TV/film adaptation could work very well indeed incorporating these beautiful small moments within the novel into a visual narrative.
Other Names For Love is published by Harvill Secker on 7th July 2022. Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the advance review copy.
2 thoughts on “Other Names For Love – Taymour Soomro (Harvill Secker 2022)”
perhaps you needed from the author too much.Perhaps this IMPRESSISNESS description of characters is AS FAR AS HE IS allowed to go as author.remember their society DOESN’T ALLOW HIM TO EXPRESS HIMSELF FULLY, perhaps a sequel in making and tying all loose ends THERE.Many reasons why?
Thanks for your comments, Monika. Good to hear from you. I’m not convinced it was a case of culture or society here or a case of tying up loose ends. I think the narrative style the author chose with changes of viewpoint at important times and with time gaps at the narrative held this reader back from being drawn into the book. It’s not a long novel so I feel it could have really been fleshed out and then it could have been very good indeed.