Andrew Holleran’s 1978 debut “Dancer From The Dance” was amongst the first prominent novels written from the gay male experience which infiltrated the mainstream. I read it probably before I was ready for it and it’s a novel I thought I would revisit one day as it is now established within the gay writing canon and is pretty rare as it was both written and set in the hedonistic post-Stonewall pre-AIDS era.
In a career where publications have been sporadic I was surprised by the news of this his 5th novel and was very interested to explore this writer’s perspectives 44 years on from that debut. I cannot fault the quality of the writing but from my personal standpoint this is one of the most depressing books I have ever read.
It is a raw, brutally honest study of gay men, loneliness and death. This is the generation who survived the epidemic which emerged a few years after Holleran’s debut and here they are decades on being snuffed out one by one in barren, lonely lives in small town America.
The starting point is the narrator’s invitation from his sister to spend Christmas with her. This would mean a departure from his rituals and routines he carries out in his dead parents’ house to which he has returned and cannot move on from. The novel is a meditation on getting old, of still not being able to fit in, of loneliness and a paranoid fear of the future for that can only involve greater isolation, sickness and death. Much of it features the slow demise of the narrator’s friend, Earl, ten years his senior and surviving to get through his pile of old movie DVDs whilst being observed closely by the narrator for parallels to his own situation and what this would mean for him in the not too distant future.
There’s no real physical decline in the narrator. His home environment has shrunk him to a fearful shadow roaming the streets at night, even though he has friends, seems to regularly travel to Washington and still functions as a sexual being but for him his outlook is totally bleak.
Such nihilistic writing might have really appealed were I not on the wrong side of 50. There’s too many nerves being touched and too much triggering going on for this to be anything but a difficult read. There’s also the issue of lightness and shade. There’s little lightness here, where there is humour it is so black it actually drags the reader down further rather than providing relief. Writers like Douglas Stuart have very successfully shown huge ability recently in making difficult subjects not only readable but very entertaining. There’s a balance to be struck, I feel, but Holleran does not permit this here. I’m wondering if this could at least be partly down to the difference between American and British viewpoints where we have a tendency to seek for humour in the darkest times. I can’t just say this book is not for me and leave it at that because this book is exactly for me, but like when I read “Dancer From The Dance” all those years ago, I’m not sure I’m ready for it.
However, all this being said there are very important issues Holleran raises here and he is doing so in a style which will linger on in the reader’s mind and his writing is engrossing and actually really quite seductive (okay, it can be repetitive but I’m putting this down to emphasis). It is no way a disappointment and has the potential to garner much critical praise and win awards but it is just very difficult to see things laid so bare and I felt quite relieved when I finished this book.
The Kingdom Of Sand is published on 9th June 2022 in the UK by Jonathan Cape. Many thanks to the publishers and Netgalley for the advance review copy.