Two series began this week which have attracted considerable pre-transmission publicity. I watched them both and one was exactly what I was expecting and one certainly wasn’t.
Sky seems to have been pushing Catherine The Great for ages. With Dame Helen Mirren as its star and its executive producer this is no surprise. This wasn’t quite enough to get me tuning in but add to that the presence of Gina McKee and Rory Kinnear in the cast and an interview with the Dame on Graham Norton’s TV show last week and I decided that this was probably going to be a must. I admit to knowing very little about Catherine The Great, Mirren was keen to point out that most of what people have heard is false anyway, outrageous stories perpetrated by rivals. These stories tended to have been based upon her reputed sexual voracity and tales of her being crushed to death whilst attempting to have sex with a horse! I had prepared myself for a very different telling of her tale from Sky Atlantic – this was not “The Borgias” after all!
Towards the end of the first episode I was aware that there was something not quite right with it but couldn’t exactly put me finger on what it was but I was surprisingly a little bored. This means that I am probably not going to watch the other three episodes. It is big budget but it doesn’t look it and that might be part of the problem. Much of it seemed to be filmed in a kind of greasy half-light which created a kind of soft-focus on the main actors and, true, that type of lighting may have been authentic for a Russian palace, but as we’ve all been pressurised into purchasing TVs with high quality picture definition it all looked somewhat flat. It was if that flatness rubbed off on other aspects of it. It certainly did not give me the costume drama lift that I’m getting on a Sunday night with “Sanditon”. It may be redressing the balance on stories about Catherine The Great but I fear I might not be sticking around to find out.
There were also royal frocks in the much anticipated “Rupaul’s Drag Race UK” A multi Emmy award-winning institution in the US this show has not to date being served terribly well by UK mainstream TV. The first series were tucked away on a channel I don’t even now remember. Most of us have caught up to date binge-watching on Netflix (I don’t think there are as many past series on here as there were) and catching the All-Stars spin-off version when it snuck out here on Comedy Central. It has a strong cult following over here who are very loyal to the show which has led to events like Season 6 winner Bianca Del Rio bringing her one-woman show over to Wembley and Australian drag queen runner Courtney Act from the same season winning “Celebrity Big Brother”. Rupaul has been around to do publicity (including a stint on the sofa with Graham Norton alongside Dame Helen Mirren) and the show’s main judge Michelle Visage is currently wowing millions each week on “Strictly Come Dancing“. So far, so good, but why is the show being aired on BBC3, the internet and I-Player platform probably depriving itself o the big mainstream audience it gets in the US?
Michelle Visage and Rupaul
Drag has a very strong culture in the UK, but that culture is different from the US. Over here we have had a tradition of drag acts who have become part of the mainstream- Lily Savage, Dame Edna, Hinge and Brackett for example, but these were primarily character-based. Only with Danny La Rue did we have a household name where the image and dresses were more important than what the act did. In the US there is a strong tradition of the Pageant Queen where the look is everything. This has now evolved into boys on Instagram gaining big followings putting together various looks with the emphasis switching away from the character and comedy of drag which has existed since over here since Music Hall days and more loosely back to Shakespeare and further to creating looks and putting together costumes.
Now in the US comedy will often win out with previous winners having a strong established act like Bianco Del Rio and Bob The Drag Queen and one of my favourites not to win, Ben De La Crème. When Drag Race was announced for the UK I thought it would be a chance to provide a platform for those performing flat out nightly entertaining in bars and clubs across the country often working tirelessly for raising funds for charities to be given a nudge into the mainstream. (Years ago Anne Robinson did helm a Weakest Link Drag Queen Special which did celebrate these) but that hasn’t really happened here with this selection of participants.
Still, we’ve got weeks to get to know them (episodes are being dropped onto the I-Player weekly) and the format, as expected, works perfectly well with a UK twist. The big prizes of the American version have gone (it is the BBC after all) and there’s still the hit and miss aspect of the challenges (being photographed on green screen as a beheaded queen – MISS, dressing up for the runway in looks inspired by our present actual Queen – HIT) and this show is likely to be a talking point throughout its run. Much of the heart of the US version comes away from the contest, when we find out about the lives of the participants facing challenges from families, religion and the geographical location. How this will translate to the British version remains to be seen but I suspect it will not be such a strong feature of the show.
Such was the attention this premiere got that I found myself doing something I never do if I’m intending to write my own review and read a couple on the morning after transmission from The Daily Telegraph and The Guardian who awarded it 3 and 4 stars respectively. The Telegraph felt it overly crude but The Guardian reviewer was certainly along for the ride and lapped it all up. I’m going along with The Guardian, it’s not the five star review I gave to the opener of Rupaul’s Drag Race All Stars Season 3 but I’m confident it will continue to win me over and bring a big blast of glam and glitter into this autumn/winter.
Ratings – Catherine The Great –
Rupaul’s Drag Race UK – 4*
Catherine The Great is on Sky Atlantic on Thursdays at 9pm. The first episode can be found on Sky catch-up services. Rupaul’s Drag Race UK can be found on the I-Player where new episodes will appear on Thursdays at 8pm.